Current Affairs-Topics

Challenges of the Smart Cities Initiative

Launched in 2015, India's Smart Cities Mission aimed to revamp urban areas by developing 100 cities with modern infrastructure and sustainable practices. However, nearly a decade later, the initiative has faced significant challenges and criticism, with many projects falling short of their intended goals. The concept of a “smart city” in India has often been misunderstood as merely providing basic amenities, rather than incorporating advanced technologies as is commonly seen in global examples.

What is a Smart City?

A smart city is generally defined as an urban area that utilizes digital technology to improve performance across sectors such as transport, energy, and waste management.

In India, the focus has been more on addressing basic infrastructure needs, while incorporating some smart solutions, which contrasts with the global definition that typically emphasizes advanced technology and operational efficiency.

Objectives of the Smart Cities Mission

  • Improve core infrastructure and quality of life.

  • Promote a clean and sustainable environment.

  • Implement smart solutions to address urban challenges.

  • Support sustainable and inclusive development.

Key Components of the Mission

  • Area-Based Development (ABD): Includes retrofitting, redevelopment, and greenfield projects.

  • Pan-City Solutions: Involves implementing Information and Communication Technology (ICT) across various sectors.

Governance Structure

The governance model relied on Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) formed under the Companies Act, which bypassed local governments.

The idea was that corporate-like structures would produce better outcomes, but this model has been criticized for lacking accountability and failing to involve the public.

Challenges Faced

The Smart Cities Mission has encountered several issues, such as:

  • Lack of Clarity: There is no clear definition of a smart city, leading to poor allocation of resources.

  • Top-Down Approach: Excluding elected representatives undermines democratic governance.

  • Flawed City Selection: The competitive selection process ignored the unique challenges faced by individual cities.

  • Inadequate Funding: The financial resources provided were not enough to meet the mission's ambitious objectives.

Case Study – Shimla

Shimla became a smart city after initially being excluded and facing legal challenges.

Its plan included improving old areas (retrofitting) and constructing new ones (redevelopment), with a focus on better pedestrian and traffic management. However, progress has been slow, and many aspects have been ineffective.

Financial Details

  • The total budget for Shimla’s smart city project was ₹2,906 crore.

  • Funding sources included Public-Private Partnerships (PPP), municipal bonds, and government schemes.

  • As of now, only ₹707 crore has been spent, with much of the funds underutilized or poorly managed.

Challenges in Shimla’s Project

  • Many key projects remain incomplete.

  • Traffic congestion has worsened, rather than improved.

  • Plans for walkways and non-motorized mobility have been neglected.

  • Money has been wasted on unimportant items like flower pots.

  • Large escalator structures were built but are not operational and obstruct views, adding to the inefficiency.

Current Status and Future Prospects

The mission, originally set for completion by 2020, has faced multiple delays, with the most recent deadline pushed to June 2024. Overall progress has been slow, and many projects are still incomplete or poorly executed.

Recommendations for Improvement

Experts suggest the following steps to improve the Smart Cities Mission:

  • Appointing dedicated CEOs for better governance.

  • Involving local stakeholders in planning and execution.

  • Focusing on comprehensive, city-wide projects for integrated urban development.

  • Strengthening the capacity of Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) to improve project outcomes.

The experiences from the Smart Cities Mission underscore the importance of public participation, strong governance, and a clear vision for urban development in India.

More Related Articles

S-400 Missile System India 2025

India has once again demonstrated its growing technological and strategic might with the effective deployment of the S-400 missile system, India 2025.  This state-of-the-art air defence syst

Indian Rupee Fall 2025

The recent Indian Rupee fall 2025 has drawn major attention from economists, traders, and policymakers. Triggered by escalating India-Pakistan tensions under Operation Sindoor, this sharp depre

Viksit Krishi Sankalp Abhiyan 2025

Union Agriculture Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan led the Ministry of Agriculture to start the Viksit Krishi Sankalp Abhiyan 2025, which is a big project. This Government agricultural awareness ca

Air Defence Activation India

In the wake of rising tensions along India's borders, particularly following Operation Sindoor, India's air defence system has been activated to safeguard its sovereignty. As part of the str

Operation Abhyaas 2025

Operation Abhyaas 2025 is a large-scale civil defence mock drill initiated by the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) across Delhi and multiple Indian states.  This MHA civil defence operati

India’s Operation Sindoor

The recent Pahalgam terror attack on April 22, 2025, where 26 innocent civilians were killed in Baisaran Valley, Jammu and Kashmir, marked a tragic event that shook the nation.  In retaliation

Colonel Sofiya Qureshi Briefing

Rising as a potent emblem of bravery, skill, and equality in India's defense scene is Colonel Sofiya Qureshi, an Indian Army officer. Her pivotal role in the media briefing on Operation Sindo

50% Reservation Cap Removal

The issue of 50% reservation cap removal has been a topic of ongoing debate in India, especially in light of recent developments regarding the caste census. Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge

WAVES Summit India 2025

More than 77 nations gathered at the WAVES Summit India, which was a component of the Global Media Dialogue, to talk about the future of the media and entertainment sector. The summit addressed m

Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996

The Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 is among India's most landmark statutes regarding the settlement of disputes, especially those involving business matters. It aims to be a good subst

Toppers

anil kumar
Akshay kuamr
geeta kumari
shubham